Policy paper · June 2026

PAYE Paid:
taxed without rights.

Closing a PAYE gap that imposes taxes without rights, penalises responsible employers and creates an underclass of unfairly disadvantaged workers.

Written by Rebecca Seeley Harris4 June 202625 pages
Download PAYE Paid
Cover of PAYE Paid: Taxed without rights

01 / The policy problem

Employment-style taxation should carry employment-style accountability.

PAYE Paid examines the growing separation between payroll treatment and employment rights. Individuals may have PAYE or employee National Insurance deducted while holiday pay, pension treatment, statutory payments and even the identity of the responsible party are denied, diluted or obscured.

The mismatch harms workers, allows non-compliant labour models to undercut responsible businesses and leaves enforcement bodies dealing with disconnected parts of the same problem.

The central propositionTax should trigger rights.

Where employment-style deductions are imposed, baseline rights and one clearly accountable entity should follow.

02 / The programme

Five reforms for accountability

The paper proposes a targeted programme that protects genuine self-employment while closing the practical loophole that allows deductions without corresponding rights.

01

Tax triggers rights

PAYE or Class 1 National Insurance treatment should create at least a rebuttable presumption of worker-level protection unless genuine self-employment is proved.

02

One binding statement

Before work begins, one document should identify the asserted status and who is responsible for payroll, holiday pay, pensions, statutory payments and enforcement.

03

Honest legal labels

Terms such as PAYE freelancer, consultant and independent contractor should not be used to obscure the worker's true legal position or entitlements.

04

Chain accountability

Agencies, umbrellas, payroll providers and, where appropriate, end clients should not be able to fragment responsibility for core rights across the supply chain.

05

Coordinated enforcement

The Fair Work Agency, HMRC and government departments should identify and act on models where payroll deductions operate without corresponding rights or a named liable entity.

03 / Where the gap appears

Different labels.
The same structural problem.

Elective Deduction ModelsNHS Direct EngagementSo-called PAYE freelancersUmbrella and agency chainsInside-IR35 statutory comparatorsNICs-only and split-treatment anomaliesPensions and fragmented engagementsPublic-sector procurement

04 / Download

Read the full PAYE Paid policy paper.

Complete the short form to download the June 2026 paper. PAYE Paid is Rebecca Seeley Harris's independent paper and is not presented as an adopted Forum position. The paper has been sent to Ministers for consideration.

We use your details to provide the download and understand interest in the paper. See our privacy policy.